consumption cleavages

consumption sectors, consumption cleavages
Social divisions created by the way in which material goods and services-especially major items such as housing, health, and education-are consumed in advanced capitalist societies.
For the most part sociologists have ignored the possible significance of patterns of consumption in determining social stratification -although Max Weber observed that status groups are ‘stratified according to the principles of their consumption of goods’ and Thorstein Veblen analysed the conspicuous consumption of the so-called leisure class . However, debates about housing classes and collective consumption during the 1960s and 1970s led some sociologists to claim that consumption-based, rather than production-based, cleavages are of increasing significance. In Britain this claim has been reinforced by psephological studies which claim to show that, during the 1980s, the public/private housing-tenure divide became more important than social class in determining voting behaviour (the so-called dealignment thesis).
According to a leading theorist of consumption cleavages, ‘a sociological analysis of the different patterns of consumption-state provision in kind, state provision in cash, self-provisioning, and marketed or privatized provisioning-is … central to an understanding of certain key features of contemporary social organization’ (, Social Theory and the Urban Question, 1986). In practice, discussion has concentrated on private (market) and socialized (state) provision, since (according to Saunders) the main consumption-based division in contemporary capitalist societies is between those who satisfy their needs through personal ownership and those who remain reliant on socialized state provision. Moreover, given the choice, those who can afford to do so choose privatized and market-based, in preference to socialized, consumption-for example of housing, health care, and education. This undermines political support for welfare regimes (and parties which promote them) and has negative effects on the quality of what welfare institutions provide for those who remain dependent on them. This creates a major social division between a ‘marginalised and stigmatised minority … cast adrift on the water-logged raft of what remains of the welfare state’, and a privatized majority, with increasing freedom to choose among better-quality market-based consumption possibilities.
There are many criticisms of this theory of sectional cleavages. Increasingly, sociologists accept the need for a closer analysis of the relationship between differing modes of consumption and possible social divisions these create, but many reject Saunders 's (possibly normatively derived) conclusions about the merits and demerits of privatized and socialized provision respectively. A majority would probably question whether consumption cleavages rather than (say) social class determines life-chances, social identity, and political alignments. There is some evidence that consumption cleavages are class-dependent rather than independent determinants of social processes. Some critics have argued that the theory is ethnocentric (being mainly concerned with the situation in Britain); others argue that the distinction between socialized and market-based consumption is unrealistic, since the public sector frequently supports apparently privatized consumption. Empirical studies have also shown that attitudes to welfarism vary according to the particular social service under discussion and that the major determinant of voting behaviour (at least in Britain) is still social class. The debate about these findings has led to some further refinements of the original theory which, together with developments elsewhere in sociology, has contributed to a growing volume of literature on the sociology of consumption.

Dictionary of sociology. 2013.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • consumption cleavage — consumption cleavages …   Dictionary of sociology

  • consumption sectors — consumption sectors, consumption cleavages Social divisions created by the way in which material goods and services especially major items such as housing, health, and education are consumed in advanced capitalist societies. For the most part… …   Dictionary of sociology

  • consumption, sociology of — An as yet ill defined and extremely diverse field of sociology that developed rapidly during the 1980s. Its substantive focus is the material culture (especially the mass culture) of advanced capitalist societies. The essays collected together in …   Dictionary of sociology

  • collective consumption — This concept was central to neo Marxist urban social theories developed in the late 1960s and 1970s. Manuel Castells and others argued that advanced capitalism required increasing state involvement in the so called means of collective consumption …   Dictionary of sociology

  • sectoral cleavages — See consumption sectors …   Dictionary of sociology

  • ПОТРЕБЛЕНИЯ РАЗЛИЧИЯ — (CONSUMPTION CLEAVAGES) В рамках многих социологических исследований предполагалось, что социальный класс является источником важного социального деления. Однако в последнее время часть социологов утверждает, что по ряду причин деление на классы… …   Социологический словарь

  • voting behaviour — Voting is the main form of political participation in liberal democratic societies and the study of voting behaviour is a highly specialized sub field within political science . The analysis of voting patterns invariably focuses on the… …   Dictionary of sociology

  • ECONOMIC HISTORY — This article is arranged according to the following outline: first temple period exile and restoration second temple period talmudic era muslim middle ages medieval christendom economic doctrines early modern period sephardim and ashkenazim… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • international relations — a branch of political science dealing with the relations between nations. [1970 75] * * * Study of the relations of states with each other and with international organizations and certain subnational entities (e.g., bureaucracies and political… …   Universalium

  • Europe, history of — Introduction       history of European peoples and cultures from prehistoric times to the present. Europe is a more ambiguous term than most geographic expressions. Its etymology is doubtful, as is the physical extent of the area it designates.… …   Universalium

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.